Episode 140

Daniel Barber came from good Puritan stock and was a fine upstanding Congregationalist minister. Until some Episcopalians convinced him that Apostolic Succession matters when it comes to ministerial Orders. So he became an Episcopalian priest. He was a fine, upstanding Episcopalian priest for many years. He and his wife, Chloe, raised three children as good Episcopalians. But eventually the question of Apostolic Succession came back to him, and he realized that Episcopalianism didn’t satisfy the question of Apostolic Succession — the Catholics actually had it, and the Episcopalians didn’t. Meantime, his son Virgil had also become a fine, upstanding Episcopalian priest. He and his wife, Jerusha, were in charge of a good school and had a comfortable life with their children. But a chance encounter with a pamphlet on the life of St. Francis Xavier fired his heart to seek the faith that motivated a man like St. Francis to do what he’d done.

Eventually, Virgil and Jerusha became Catholic. Then Chloe converted, along with a number of other members of the family. And finally, Daniel also became Catholic.

The entire affair was very upsetting to fine, upstanding New England Protestant sensibilities, and caused a sensation.

But the sensations didn’t end there. The rest, however, is a tale for another time.

Follow to Get Episodes Automatically

And in your kindness, please leave a great rating and a review — those help more people to find American Catholic History!

Amazon MusicApple PodcastsGoogle PodcastsOvercastPocketCastsRSSSpotifyStitcherTuneInYouTube

Support American Catholic History

Noëlle and Tom enjoy doing this work, but they can't do it without support!

Become a supporter of American Catholic History to keep this great Catholic content coming.

Locals logo

Over on Locals we host reading groups, post exclusive videos, chat sessions, and we share more content not available to the public. 

Join Our Locals Community

Patron Logo

Learn how you can sponsor the American Catholic History Podcast. Your name and information will be included in our episodes, plus more benefits. Get information at the SQPN website.

Become a Patron

Drop a Tip in Noëlle & Tom's Tip Jar

Putting these episodes together takes time. If you appreciate what you get, show Noëlle and Tom a little love through Venmo or Paypal.

Stay Connected

We'll share occasional updates about upcoming Pilgrimages, publications, show topics, catechetical resources, and more.

Please Send Me...

7 + 11 =

Most Recent